INTRODUCTION: Below are some of the documented
complaints that we have received over the past year or so. They are from nineteen Woodstock area
residents, families or households who have given their permission that we share
them publicly. They are representative
of other comments/complaints we have received, both verbally and in writing. The notes are separated by a row of
asterisks, as immediately below, except in one series of notes that were an
e-mail dialogue over several days, where we centered the asterisks in the line
between the messages. Thank you, The
Woodstock Wind Ordinance Committee
If you don't have time to read them all, scroll down to the first
one dated 9/20/12 and read from there to the end.
one dated 9/20/12 and read from there to the end.
***********
March 16, 2012 at 11:47 AM
Thanks for the information on the Wind Ordinance Committee.
I live in Milton Twp. approx. 3 mi. from the industrial wind
site in Woodstock, so I don't know what my opinion will matter. I can hear these things at times when the
evening is calm and day to day noise has subsided. Yes, it is annoying considering I built out
here to get away from town, mill, and traffic noise. My opinion is these things do not benefit
anyone in this state other than a small amount of tax revenue. They did create
a small number of specialty jobs at unbelievable cost, in my guess, that was indirectly
paid by tax payers, [the working people]. I also wonder if taxes collected are
enough to pay for the road damage that seems worse than normal this year. Oh, I forgot to mention of having to look at
these things on the mountains that drew me in and make a home here.
Thanks for reading,
E. Milton Resident
************
April
4, 2012
We
purchased our land on Redding Road close to Shagg Pond in the summer of 2007
with plans to build in the next couple years.
We chose the location of the land for its peace and quiet, for its natural
beauty, and for its distance from things man-made. We had never heard of Patriot Renewables, and
no one in the area had any knowledge of coming wind turbines.
We
built a small cabin in the fall of 2008 and by the summer of 2010 our dreams to
build a small home came true. I remember
being on top of the roof in August of 2010 when a woman pulled up in a car and
hollered something to me about windmills.
She asked if she could leave some papers on the truck windshield and
that is the first time I remember hearing about them. This woman was apparently opposed to the idea
and was trying to gather others who felt the same way. Busy building the house, I didn’t think much
about it.
By
the summer of the following year (2011), we were living there full time but
still with a lot of work to do on the house.
That is about the time we saw things beginning to happen. There was talk that the road up near Concord
Pond would be widened and that the logging we were hearing was to clear space
for the wind farm. Sure enough, things
progressed rapidly. We began to get
literature from Patriot Renewables about the project. We could hear the heavy equipment and the
blasting.
It
must have been one day in late November or early December of 2011 that my wife
and I were inside the house and she asked me if I heard something. After listening, I replied that it was a jet
plane. We didn’t think much about it
until the next day when one of us heard what we thought was another jet. But this time we kept listening and the noise
never went away. We realized it couldn’t
be a jet unless it was circling the area.
We went outside and listened. It
was constant. It took a few moments and
then it dawned on us that the sound was the wind turbines.
Having
lived with the turbines now for several months, it has become clear that the
noise is loudest to us when the turbines are faced Northwest and the wind is
coming from that direction. Our home is
in that path and I guess that’s why. The
wind comes over the blades directly toward us.
What is most interesting to me is that they seem loudest on the calmer
days. That is, if the wind is barely
existent, I can really hear them roaring.
These
windmills have definitely impacted our home here. If we had known they would be building them
so close to us, and we’d known about it before we bought the land, we may be
living somewhere else now.
Shagg
Pond Resident
**********
4/10/12
(The following is our summary of verbal conversations with
eight people from five households.)
The turbines are very disturbing! We can’t see them much from our house, but
they are loud, annoying and distracting from all around the Pond, even down
into Sumner on the Redding Rd. On the
east side of the Pond they just loom over you!
They have changed the whole atmosphere and appreciation of the Pond for
everyone who lives here, and they’re really going to devastate the people with
camps when they show up!
Some days you hardly hear them, then others it’s loud much
of the day, even indoors with the windows closed. Quiet nights without much wind are some of
the loudest times. I hate to think what
nights will sound like in warmer weather with the windows open!
Shagg Pond Residents
**********
Sent: Monday,
April 16, 2012 8:18 AM
Subject: RE: wind ordinance committee
Subject: RE: wind ordinance committee
We would
like to voice our concerns about the low level sound emissions from the wind
towers. We are sure they do not violate the decibel levels, but after spending
many days on the pond since March we were both affected by what appears to be
the prop noise. Although they may not violate the approval levels, they
certainly will affect our lives at Concord. We spend a great amount of time
there and were hoping to spend 6 months a year on the pond as we prepare to
retire. When the wind on the pond dies down, it is still windy on the mountain.
The only noise we can hear at that time is the noise from the props. This is a
constant thumping and whooshing that is 24 hours a day. It appears to be
affecting our sleep and we have had headaches the entire time we were there
that we can definitely attribute to the noise. When we leave, the headaches
subside within a few hours.
We are
very concerned about the quality of life. We also hope that you will keep the
record open so that others get a chance to weigh in. Not many people are there
at this time of year, but more are coming back as the weather improves. The
once quiet, serene and remote pond is now going to be a nightmare for many. We
expect you will hear from others when the full impact is known.
We are
also very concerned about the wildlife and the impact this may have on their
well-being. The loons and others are returning as usual, but will this interfere
with their habitat?
Thank
you,
A Couple
on Concord Pond
********
Sent: Wednesday, April 18, 2012 8:59 AM
To: <bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net>
RE: Spruce Mountain Wind Towers and Concord Pond
We are camp owners on Concord Pond. We recently were able to get into camp for
the first time this season. Our
observations and findings regarding the wind towers were quite upsetting. They include:
Noise
Turbine noise that sounds like a plane is just about ready
to pass overhead, but never arrives
Turbine noise that intermittently produces an unnatural wind
sound; whoosh, whoosh, thump
Turbine noise that reminds you of the buzzing that occurs
when a mosquito is around your ear
No escaping the low sound emissions
Visual
The view from various places on the pond is destroyed
The simulations presented by the company did not accurately
portray the realty
Our hope is that observations will be considered should any
further wind projects be addressed by the town.
Thank you,
A Couple on Concord Pond
**********
Date: 07/27/2012 11:28 AM
Subject: Woodstock Wind Ordinance
As residents of Concord Pond in Woodstock we would like to
express our concerns about the wind ordinance being created for the Town of
Woodstock.
We support the committee's efforts to create an ordinance,
but we would propose stricter setbacks and noise levels than the current state
standards. We believe these should be located no closer than 3 miles from any
homes and that the decibel levels should be set lower.
The Spruce Mountain wind project is an industrial usage in a
rural setting. We are situated on a pond surrounded by mountains and believe
this creates a unique topography that captures the sounds of the towers on
Concord Pond. We are currently spending a great deal of time on the pond and
are experiencing sound levels and types of sounds that are detrimental to our
health. The towers may not be above the
levels required, but they are too close and repetitive. We are approximately
1.5 miles away but have been experiencing headaches, lack of sleep and are
aware of a pulsing background noise. Some days are quiet and some are nearly
unmanageable.
We understand that the Spruce Mountain project is completed
and will probably not be affected by the ordinance. We hope that Woodstock residents will take
into consideration what has and is happening to some of their neighbors as a
result of the current project and create an ordinance that will protect
everyone from future development.
Respectfully, a Couple on Concord Pond
***********
Date: 07/16/2012 08:59 PM
To: <bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net>
Subject: RE: Woodstock Wind Ordinance
I have contacted the Spruce Mountain hotline and been on the
phone with Dawn Hallowell of Maine DEP and Tetra, Patriots acoustical people.
Tetra is meeting me at our camp at Concord Pond tomorrow (Tuesday) at 12:30 PM
to set up a 5 hour monitoring. Dawn asked them for the monitoring data from the
remote monitoring site on the Concord Pond side of Spruce Mountain, and
apparently there is no data as the mice have eaten the wires. Convenient!
A Concord Pond Resident
********
From: Hallowell, Dawn <Dawn.Hallowell@maine.gov>
Date: Thu, Jul 19, 2012 at 12:31 PM
Subject: RE: Sound Monitoring for SMW
Date: Thu, Jul 19, 2012 at 12:31 PM
Subject: RE: Sound Monitoring for SMW
A mouse did eat the wires and data was not available
for the date of the Concord Pond resident’s complaint. SMW is responsible for
getting it back up and running until the Department has reviewed and issued a
decision regarding its pending amendment application to stop the requirement of
continuous sound monitoring at the facility.
Dawn Hallowell,
Licensing & Compliance Manager, Central Maine Region
Department of Environmental Protection
17 State House Station | Augusta ME 04333
Department of Environmental Protection
17 State House Station | Augusta ME 04333
**********
From: Hallowell, Dawn [mailto:Dawn.Hallowell@maine.gov]
Sent: Monday, August 06, 2012 2:57 PM
Subject: FW: Spruce Sound complaint
Mr. ----------
Here is a copy of the TechEnvironmental report from the
monitoring conducted on July 17, 2012 in response to a complaint you filed on
July 15.
The Department agrees with its expert and finds that the
project was operating in compliance on both July 17 & 19 2012.
Dawn Hallowell
Licensing & Compliance Manager, Central Maine Region
Department of Environmental Protection
********
Date: 08/07/2012 12:49 PM
To: "'Hallowell, Dawn”, Maine DEP
CC: Woodstock Wind Committee
Subject: RE: Spruce Sound complaint
Ms Dawn Hallowell
There are several points I would like to touch
on concerning the sound test report done on July 17 by Tech Environmental.
First of all the noise level that I witnessed during the sound
test on July 17th was NOT at the same level as when the complaint was made on
July 15th. The sound technician reports
in the paragraph on page 2 of the report, and I quote, “The SMW turbines
operated under wind conditions that produced maximum sound power on July 17
(hub-height winds above 8 m/s), and operated at a higher level than at the time
of the complaint on July 15 when hub-height average wind speeds were below 8
m/s. Power production by the four closest turbines (T8 through T11) at the time
of the complaint totaled 1,103 kW and were relatively low all day on July 15.
By comparison, power production by these same four turbines during the sound
compliance test was higher, in the range of 1,699 kW to 2,397 kW." He then makes the assumption that, “Thus,
there is a greater POTENTIAL for turbine sound impacts during the test on July
17 than at the time of the noise complaint on July 15.” I can attest that on July 15 (for whatever
reason) the noise was much louder than on the day of the sound test July
17. Conditions were not the same as
Tetra contended, as I was at the camp on both days!
Secondly, I would like to say that the jet sound we hear at
the pond is from the turbines and not a jet going overhead. There is a difference
as the Jet goes away; however, the turbine jet sound varies with wind direction
and may not go away for hours. I point to the local Bethel Citizen weekly
newspaper released on July 26 2012. The headlines are, “Neighbors of Spruce
Mountain Wind complain of ‘aircraft’, ‘freight train’ like sounds”, and these
claims are made by several people, not just me - whom the sound technician
quickly, (without any basis), dismisses.
After several days of quietness and low level noise on
Concord Pond, (during which time the towers appeared to be shut down for hours
at a time), the towers once again reached the level of great annoyance on
August 4. At approximately 10:30 – 11:00pm on August 4 until 1:00am on August
5, and again between approximately 5:00 am – 7: am August 5, the towers were
very annoying. I called in the complaint on the morning of August 6 as I did
not have the hotline number with me at the time it was occurring. Spruce
Mountain Wind’s representative immediately called me back and stated that he was
talking to a Concord Pond resident with a camp on the opposite end of the lake
from us, and that camp owner stated that a plane was buzzing the pond at
approximately 11:15 on the night of August 4. I acknowledged that there was a
helicopter that passed over our end of the pond directly over our camp, and it
appeared to be a life flight. It passed over our camp at low level and was gone
in less than 15 seconds. It later returned on its path presumably to the
Lewiston/Auburn facilities approximately ½ hour later, again being gone from
hearing distance within 15 seconds. No
plane was buzzing the pond. Before, during, and for some time after the
helicopter had returned - the wind towers were very annoying. Whoosh – Whoosh
and an occasional distant jet sound was present. This reoccurred in the morning of August 5
between 5am and 7am.
Conclusion: The SMW representative has told me they are
working on the problem to try and see what is going on, so as to come up with a
solution. I appreciate this and offer my services in any way I might be of
help. I for one love Concord Pond and hope to be able to spend many more years
enjoying what Concord Pond has offered in the past: quiet solitude at night
with daytime sounds of kids and loons enjoying the pond.
Witnessing what I have so far this summer on the few times I
have been able to go to the pond – I believe that a return to this is not
likely going to happen. I believe that
further setbacks are required in the mountain regions, especially within the
reaches of our ponds, as evident with Concord.
I do hope however, that this can be resolved at Concord Pond
so that my only resort is NOT to try and find another water body to reside on.
Thank you for your help
Sincerely,
A Concord Pond Resident
***********
Date: 08/08/2012 09:04 AM
To: <bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net>
Subject: Sound test
I meant to attach this to the last email.
FYI, SMW is holding a meeting at the wind tower maintenance
building on the Shagg Pond Road @ 6pm on 8/14/2012. They are getting together
to hammer out details on setting up a two-week sound study at the north end of
the Pond. I have been invited to attend – which I will. I will keep you
informed if you are not invited.
My biggest concerns are that the test is being put together
with Spruce Mountain Wind’s knowledge. I
feel it’s like the fox protecting the chicken pen. I think that a third party
sound test should be done on a surprise basis during a time at which they do
not know they are being monitored.
Because SMW can, at all times, control the speed of the turbines, they
are currently at the controls of all test results. I for one am not comfortable
with this conflict of interest.
I understand it is a step in the right direction and welcome
the test, but hold little confidence, at this time, that it will accurately
depict the levels we are hearing at random times on the pond. I suspect that
this is not the last step.
A Concord Pond Resident
**********
Date: 07/19/2012 04:21 PM
To: bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net
Subject: Please support wind turbine ordinance
Dear Woodstock Residents,
I am writing to ask your support for the ordinance to put
regulations and controls in place concerning wind power in our town. Wind
energy companies and town governments must improve their communication with
property owners, and compensate owners most negatively impacted.
Impact:
I am a long time summer resident. My family bought a cottage
on the East Shore of Shagg Pond 40 plus years ago. Four generations of my
family have come to enjoy the quiet peaceful landscape, listen to the loons and
swim in the refreshing waters of Shagg Pond. Each family member has been
shocked upon arriving this summer to find 3 huge wind turbines looming above
and directly in front of our cottage. We can see and hear 9 turbines but 3 are
so close, and at times so loud, that our cottage environment is no longer
peaceful.
Poor Communication:
The town never sent any official, unbiased information to
out-of-town tax payers so the only source of information we received was from
Patriot Energy. Public Meetings were advertised only in newspapers that summer
residents don’t typically subscribe to. As summer residents we were left out of
the loop and the wind turbines are a done deal without us having any input.
Misleading Information:
When I heard about the wind turbines from a year-round
resident I called Patriot Energy. The information I was given was misleading
and the only information they offered was via their website and infrequent
newsletter. I was told that they would not be visible from Shagg Pond and I
would only be able to see the turbines if I could see the meteorological test
tower. From my view, the test tower was
off to the side and partially hidden. Turns out, the turbines are VERY visible
from my east shore. I directly face them and they are 400 feet high. Nothing to
block the sound or sight. When it is windy the noise is terrible. WUMP, WUMP,
WUMP - plus a jet plane going overhead, but it never passes.
Loss without compensation:
I assumed that I would be receiving a tax abatement since my
property has obviously lost value. The town
does not plan to do re-assessments. I was told they rely only on sales data, so
until someone sells their property, there will be no abatements. All the
cottages on the east shore have been passed down through generations, so the
families who have lost property value and quality of life will not be
compensated in any way - No reduction in energy costs and no tax abatement.
This is very unfair. I feel like I have been robbed!
A Shagg Pond Family
***********
Date: 07/19/2012 02:22 PM
To: bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net
My wife and I have owned our camp on Shagg Pond for
approximately 10 years. We live and work in Brunswick, Maine. Our camp has
provided us with a sanctuary and escape from the daily grind for many years.
Shagg Pond has always been abundant in natural beauty and solitude, and I have
always felt very fortunate to own a small piece of property so rich in beauty
and so close to home.
When describing my camp, I would tell my friends that it
felt like being in a far- away place. The only sounds were those of nature;
wind, water, loons and the occasional passing motorist or barking dog.
Last year I was informed of the Patriot Wind Energy turbine
project. I read everything available, including the noise propagation study, to
prepare myself for the coming shift. I am a retired paper mill electrical
engineer, so technology is something I understand and appreciate.
I watched with interest as the turbine construction advanced
and was finally completed. I even took the tour to get a closer look at the
completed project. My first experience visiting my camp after turbine startup
was discouraging. The wind direction was such that the turbines atop Spruce Mt.
were in a direct line with my camp. The noise was something akin to the low deep
rumble of a freight train in combination with a passing jet aircraft. I was
disheartened by the noise but also in the realization that Shagg Pond would
never again be the magnificent natural sanctuary many generations had loved and
treasured for so long.
Being an engineer, I mostly consider myself unlucky. We are told that wind turbine technology is
the future. My camp was once a gem. Now, not so much. More care in planning and
execution of turbine siting could virtually eliminate or greatly reduce much of
the public anger. The 2 most northerly turbines closest to Shagg Pond likely
contribute 90% of the noise radiated to the Shagg Pond basin.
As with all large revenue producing projects, economics are
at play. Low density residential areas present a low economic risk, when
measured against litigation costs and the intangible cost of public protests.
An intelligent compromise is real and exists within the
ordinance that is being presented by local Woodstock residents. An ordinance
will empower the town and provide protection to its citizens to the extent
defined by its citizens. Patriot Wind Energy is motivated by profits. Period. I
don't doubt they have an interest in being a good corporate neighbor. But an
ordinance is like insurance, ready and available, only when needed. It helps encourage and enforce a process of
checks and balances, protecting all citizens.
My wife and I accept the Patriot Wind Energy project as it
exists, but strongly believe a well written ordinance would encourage the implementation
of best practices into the management of future wind projects.
Sincerely,
A Couple on Shagg
Pond
***********
Date: 08/07/2012 06:01 AM
Subject: Loud Days
Saturday night and all day Sunday were excessive. We were
with friends on the south end of the Pond, and they thought it loud, too. We
will not forget to call you the next time!
We will be back up on Saturday until Tuesday. Thanks for your concern!
A Couple on Concord Pond
************
Date: 08/08/2012 05:45 PM
To: bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net
Subject: Loud Days
Very loud this morning between 4:40 say till about 6:00.
Thanks,
Shagg Pond Resident
************
Date: 08/10/2012 08:50 PM
To: <bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net>
Subject: RE: Sound test
Thanks for your suggestion of inviting Committee and other
interested Woodstock residents to our end of the pond to hear the turbines when
they are loud. It would probably be best
that you bring people to the public boat
ramp at Concord Pond to observe the towers rather than to someone’s private
property.
We need to stop this assault on the public as they are
unaware of what is about to happen to them if a project is within their hearing
range. We will likely have to relocate to reach the serenity that we have known
at Concord Pond for so many years, but if we can save one other family from the
same demise, we are here to help!
Thanks for listening and for your support,
A Concord Pond Resident
**********
Date: 08/13/2012 03:16 PM
To: <bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net>
Re: A Neighbor’s Complaint
We have a camp on the north end of Concord Pond, and a
neighbor told us today of her recent turbine noise experience. Late last week she was jogging with her I-Pod
on, and the wind tower noise was so loud it was interfering with her hearing
the songs. She said that she called the Spruce Mountain Wind hotline, but no
one has gotten back to her. I wonder if
that might be due to the recommendation of Patriot’s acoustical people that
they no longer address noise complaints from our side of the pond!
The relevant parts of Tech Environmental’s report following
their investigation into other recent noise complaints are pasted below:
*****
August
13, 2012
Ms.
Dawn Hallowell, Licensing & Compliance Manager, Maine DEP
Re:
Independent Review of the Noise Complaints from the north end of Concord Pond,
August 4, 5, and 6, Spruce Mountain Wind
Tech
Environmental, Inc. (TE) has completed an independent review of the noise
complaints lodged by X and Y. X called on August 6 and stated the “towers were
really annoying” on Saturday August 4 starting at 11 p.m., and again on Sunday
August 5 at 5 a.m. Y called twice, first at 7:30 a.m. on Sunday, August 5 and
said the “towers are quite loud,” and again at 6:40 a.m. on Monday August 6.
Conclusions
Regarding Future Complaints
From
the measurements and data analyzed in the two sets of complaints regarding the
X and Y properties on July 24-25 and August 4-6, and from the measurements TE
made on X’s property on July 17, it is my professional opinion that any turbine
related sounds heard on the north side of Concord Pond will not exceed 45 dBA
at their properties on Concord Pond. Forty-five dBA is the lowest Maine DEP
sound limit in the SMW SLOD permit. Thus, there is no need for Tech
Environmental to do a quantitative analysis of sound levels in response to any
future complaints that may be received from residents on the north side of
Concord Pond.
Sincerely
yours,
TECH
ENVIRONMENTAL, INC.
Peter
H. Guldberg, INCE, CCM
*****
I for one am outraged!!!
A Concord Pond Resident
*************
Date: 8/30/2012 08:20 AM
Dear Wind Committee,
Today is a good day to come and listen to the windmills near our house. They are as loud as I have heard them, especially persistent and disconcerting. The weather is clear with no wind in our valley but a northerly wind on the ridge.
Shagg Pond Resident
**********
Date: 09/20/2012 06:16 AM
Subject: RE: SMW Noise Test
I called the SMW hot line again this last weekend. It has been awful. We believe that now it is September and the winds are more prominent, we may be hearing them a bit more like they would normally be prior to the quieter spell of the previous two or three weeks. If that is the case, I don't see how we will survive. My husband is hearing it at night now and understands the blood sounds in our heads while trying to sleep.
The Sound Study equipment is still on the shore of the Pond, and we've heard no responses or calls from anyone about its results. The blood noise I mention above is what happens at night. I wake up and my head aches and is pounding. I had one night that the pain was so bad I could not lift my head from the pillow. My husband and I compared notes and it feels like our blood pressure/pulse are reverberating in our heads in sync with the towers. This weekend the windows were closed because it was cold and the noise was not as loud, but I still woke up every hour or so with the pounding. I’m hoping to find time to read some articles on wind turbine syndrome. We also spend more time at our camp than nearly anyone else on the pond. That may be why we are more in tune to them.
Prior to the last few weeks it was loud only on random days. Since Labor Day (or thereabouts) it seems to be 24/7 every weekend. The wind is obviously more prominent now. Think we just had such a hot, quiet summer that it was not happening that often. All visitors have noticed and said that it may be below the requirements, but that it not something that they could live with. We have tried to keep an open mind and see if we can live with it, but after the last three weekends it doesn't bode well.
We are devastated. We are currently in the process of selling our house - on the market two days and already have an offer! So we will not make any decisions yet as we need to wait until we are resettled.
I know this is the emotional part, but this was our dream. We have had a tough life and the last few years have been good to us, so we were able to buy a camp and help make a dream come true. We searched for two years for something we could afford, and we have been so happy there. We know we will not get what we paid for it 5 years ago, let alone the money we have put into it structurally. When we purchased it the front porch was totally rotten, there was no outhouse and the camp was falling over. We have put our hearts and souls into this and still had so many plans. We had hoped to live there six months of the year starting in 2013.
A Couple on Concord Pond
Subject: RE: SMW Noise Test
I called the SMW hot line again this last weekend. It has been awful. We believe that now it is September and the winds are more prominent, we may be hearing them a bit more like they would normally be prior to the quieter spell of the previous two or three weeks. If that is the case, I don't see how we will survive. My husband is hearing it at night now and understands the blood sounds in our heads while trying to sleep.
The Sound Study equipment is still on the shore of the Pond, and we've heard no responses or calls from anyone about its results. The blood noise I mention above is what happens at night. I wake up and my head aches and is pounding. I had one night that the pain was so bad I could not lift my head from the pillow. My husband and I compared notes and it feels like our blood pressure/pulse are reverberating in our heads in sync with the towers. This weekend the windows were closed because it was cold and the noise was not as loud, but I still woke up every hour or so with the pounding. I’m hoping to find time to read some articles on wind turbine syndrome. We also spend more time at our camp than nearly anyone else on the pond. That may be why we are more in tune to them.
Prior to the last few weeks it was loud only on random days. Since Labor Day (or thereabouts) it seems to be 24/7 every weekend. The wind is obviously more prominent now. Think we just had such a hot, quiet summer that it was not happening that often. All visitors have noticed and said that it may be below the requirements, but that it not something that they could live with. We have tried to keep an open mind and see if we can live with it, but after the last three weekends it doesn't bode well.
We are devastated. We are currently in the process of selling our house - on the market two days and already have an offer! So we will not make any decisions yet as we need to wait until we are resettled.
I know this is the emotional part, but this was our dream. We have had a tough life and the last few years have been good to us, so we were able to buy a camp and help make a dream come true. We searched for two years for something we could afford, and we have been so happy there. We know we will not get what we paid for it 5 years ago, let alone the money we have put into it structurally. When we purchased it the front porch was totally rotten, there was no outhouse and the camp was falling over. We have put our hearts and souls into this and still had so many plans. We had hoped to live there six months of the year starting in 2013.
A Couple on Concord Pond
************
Date: 09/20/2012 11:04 AM
To: <bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net>
Subject: RE: SMW Noise Test
Dear Committee:
Noise at Concord Pond was awful Saturday the 15th and seems
to be getting worse with the climate change and foliage drop. My wife and I
have decided that we will ready the camp for sale as it is obvious that we will
no longer enjoy the serenity of the pond. We do not see the towers from our
camp and thought we had dodged a bullet - how untrue. We sit on the deck and
start to read a book or do some studying and low and behold the wind changes
and the sound of the towers breaks our solitude.
I am truly saddened by the fact that the project was allowed
to be sighted where it is and hope that the town of Woodstock and DEP officials
realize that if they allow the project to expand that it will affect others
elsewhere in town. Maybe it will be one of them next time! I wish this on no
one and am happy for the townspeople who say they can't hear them or they are
not bothered by them. I wish I were one
of them.
I can only hold to the great many memories since first
coming here in the early 50's and wish the rest of Woodstock the best in the
future with whatever they decide. I cannot have a vote as I am not a resident.
Time to move on.
Best wishes –
A Woodstock Property Owner and Concord Pond Resident
************
Date: 12/01/2012 08:35 AM
(Phone Message)
I wanted to let you know the windmills are the loudest we've ever heard them this morning. They are absolutely roaring. The noise started a couple hours ago and woke us up. Please stop over if you can to get a dB reading.
Shagg Pond Resident
*********
Date 12/01/2012 10:02 AM
(Phone Message from same person as
directly above)
If you didn’t get my earlier
message, don’t come over. The noise has
died down in the last twenty minutes or so, and there’s now not much volume to
measure. Sorry we missed you on the
phone earlier.
Shagg Pond Resident
*********
Date: 12/01/2012 09:05 AM
(e-mail from a different resident than the two phone calls,
above.)
Just wanted to let you know the windmills are the loudest we've ever heard right now. We have music playing and the washer running and the noise is roaring above them.
Shagg Pond Resident
***********
Date: 03/06/2013 02:15 PM
To: "news@bethelcitizen.com"
<news@bethelcitizen.com>
Subject: Please support the wind ordinance for Woodstock
I applaud the members of the Woodstock wind ordinance
committee for their dedication and work on the wind ordinance. Assuming the voters of Woodstock support the
ordinance, their sacrifice of time and energy will benefit us and future
generations who value the beauty and peace of our lovely western mountains by
preventing further degradation of our landscape.
My family has owned a rustic cabin on Shagg pond in
Woodstock for over 40 years. Each spring the extended family negotiates for
their vacation time in the quiet and solitude of the pond. It is such a respite
from the stress and demands of our lives. We were all extremely disappointed
last summer to arrive and be confronted with 9 wind turbines directly in front
of the cottage. Even more disturbed by the loud jet plane noise that came up at
random times during our stays and often did not recede for hours.
We, as summer residents, although tax payers, were poorly
informed of the plans for these turbines, had no say in their approval and are
receiving no benefit from their electricity. We discovered that one of my
brothers, who lives in Concord, Mass., actually has the choice to choose the
green energy generated by these turbines.
I urge residents to support the wind ordinance and its
efforts to limit noise and intrusion of further wind turbines on the landscape
of our area.
Thank you,
A Long-Time Shagg Pond Resident
**********
Date: 3/6/13
To: Letter to the Editor, Bethel Citizen
To those that have an interest in the wind towers of Woodstock, Maine, I would encourage your support of a wind ordinance. As a camp owner on Big Concord Pond, I am writing to offer my insight and perspective on the importance of a wind ordinance for every town, large or small. Our camp was the first built on this remote wilderness pond, and it was positioned with stunning mountain views to the South. We enjoy afternoon sun, a steady breeze off the water and gorgeous sunsets.
We were not happy at the original prospect of the wind tower farm for all the reasons presented from previous projects, such as noise, flicker, flash and the ominous presence of the massive towers and blades. Unfortunately the camp owners of Big Concord Pond do not live in Woodstock and had no vote on the towers being permitted.
The wind towers have been very
bothersome when the atmospheric conditions are present to perpetuate certain
issues. When the blades are positioned toward the sun, (with a westerly wind
and afternoon western sun position), there is a reflective "flash"
for each blade of each wind tower and a "flicker" shadow from each
blade of every tower. These words- flash and flicker- held little true meaning
until we experienced the effect for ourselves. With eight towers in
our direct view, we have 24 blades spinning, catching this reflective flash and flicker. It is quite hard to look in the direction of the towers when this occurs. It literally causes some to have seizures, headache, nausea or dizziness...it definitely causes distress.
our direct view, we have 24 blades spinning, catching this reflective flash and flicker. It is quite hard to look in the direction of the towers when this occurs. It literally causes some to have seizures, headache, nausea or dizziness...it definitely causes distress.
The noise is a real problem, as well. When there is a high level wind blowing toward the pond and the pond has little or no wind at the lower levels, the noise is quite irritating- even inside the cottage. This is a common occurrence, as the pond is situated in a mountain bowl. Another big
change to our vista is the night sky. On dark nights when the best night view was of only shooting stars, we now look at flashing red tower lights.
The biggest impact to us, however, has been a business issue. In 1996 we began a vacation rental business. The Cottage became one of our several rental properties for families to enjoy in the summer weeks. We have consistently rented it between 7 and 10 weeks each summer through fall. The remote area, no electricity, serene, private location and great mountain views were our advertising promotional points. With the wind towers’ construction, we felt an obligation to our clients to inform them of the wind towers.
This is what one of our advertising sites says, "The Lake Cottage is a vintage Maine camp set within feet of the sandy beach of Concord Pond. It has a large grass yard, with a fire pit and babbling springtime stream in the back yard. There is much privacy with a small camp on one side and conservation land on the other. The water front is very private with southern mountain views and a dock with canoe for your use. This is a remote mountain pond that is very serene. The area has no electricity which adds to the charm. The cabin is equipped with gas lights and appliances and has cold running water, gravity fed from the mountain stream. A true off the grid
experience, with the ironic twist that the south-west views are of a modern wind farm supplying green energy to the rest of New England."
Even with a bad economy for several past years we have still done very well with summer rentals as this is a reasonable summer vacation without a lot of travel expense for New England families. This past summer, however, with the presence of the towers was quite a different scenario. The loss of business at the Cottage was dramatic. Several long time renters opted to look for another location. With our tax returns finished for 2012, our revenue at the camp was off by almost exactly 60% over the income from 2011.
I strongly urge residents to approve a wind ordinance before further damage is done.
Thank You,
A Concord Pond Cottage Owner
**********
Date: 12/06/2012 07:25 PM
To: bpwindcomm@oxfordnetworks.net
Subject: They are loud!
Greetings,
We owned a lot at Eagles Nest - Saunders Road, and had to
sell it back to Patriot. We were
extremely disappointed. We spent a few
nights on our lot and one evening I could not even get to sleep. The low thumping noise went on all night and
occasionally you could hear the turbine heads shifting directions. Human hearing is much more perceptive then
high tech microphones! Thankfully we
were able to sell and purchase another piece of land in a neighboring town.
Ironically we still pass the Turbines on the drive to our new peaceful
property.
Unfortunately Woodstock sold out. The area around the turbines will not be the
same until the wind turbines reach the end of their life cycle. I feel bad for anyone in striking distance.
Good luck with the continued battle,
Former Shagg Pond Area Lot Owner
***********
Date: 3/14/13
To: Letter to the Editor, Bethel Citizen
To: Letter to the Editor, Bethel Citizen
CAMP
OWNER FOR WIND ORDINANCE
To those that have an interest in the wind towers of
Woodstock Maine, I would encourage your support of a wind ordinance.
As a camp owner on Big Concord Pond, I am writing to offer
my insight and perspective on the importance of a wind ordinance for every
town, large or small. Our camp was one of the first built on this remote
wilderness pond and it was positioned with stunning mountain views to the
south. We were not happy at the original prospect of the wind tower farm for
all the reasons presented from previous projects, such as noise, flicker, flash
and the ominous presence of the massive towers and blades. We did keep an open
mind as we felt that the green energy was important. Unfortunately, we found
that the negative impact is a real concern.
The wind towers have been very bothersome when certain
conditions are present. When the blades are positioned toward the sun (with a
westerly wind and afternoon western sky sun position) so every afternoon there
is a reflective “flash” for each blade of each tower and a “flicker” shadow
from each blade of every tower. These words – flash and flicker – held little
true meaning until we experienced the effect for ourselves. With eight towers
in our direct view, we have 24 blades spinning, catching this reflective flash
and flicker. It literally causes physical symptoms; headache, nausea and/or
dizziness, even seizures in those with a predisposition – it definitely causes
distress.
The noise is a real problem as well. When there is a
high-level wind blowing and the pond has little or no wind at the lower levels,
the noise is quite irritating – even inside the cottage. This is a common
occurrence, as the pond is situated in a mountain bowl. The sound is the same
as a jet flying overhead, consistently present. The star-filled night sky is
now interrupted with constantly blinking red tower lights. Patriot was asked to
consider night lighting that came on only when planes were in the vicinity,
which is an available technology. They refused to do so, based on cost. The
town did not press the issue.
Most arguments pro and con are subjective. I would like to
provide very objective data for your consideration. We began Androscoggin Home
Rentals in 1996 as a vacation rental business. The camp became one of our
rental properties for summer vacations. We have consistently rented the cabin
between 7 and 10 weeks each summer/fall. The remote area, no electricity,
serene, private location and great mountain views were our advertising
promotional points. Even with a bad economy for the past several years, we have
done very well with summer rentals. This past summer, however, with the presence
of the towers, was quite a different scenario. The loss of business at our
rental property was dramatic. Our revenue at the camp was off by 60 percent
over the income from 2011. It was off by 50 percent the two years prior to
that. The rest of our rentals all did better last summer, so the economy was
not the factor. Our advertising was not to blame as we took the positive spin
and ended our description of the property by saying “Experience a true off the
grid experience with a twist. Our southwest views are of a modern wind farm
supplying green energy to the rest of New England.” This loss of income is not
a subjective finding. There are hard facts to support this business loss. As
property owners, we are not the only one saying, “Not in my backyard.” So are
the vacationers, who many of us depend upon for our livelihood.
We strongly urge residents to approve a wind ordinance
before further damage is done.
